Calvin Bassey vs Collins: Why Man Utd should choose Nigeria star

Premier League giants Manchester United are planning to strengthen their defence in the January transfer window, with Super Eagles star Calvin Bassey among their targets.

The Red Devils have endured a difficult start to the 2026/27 season, finding themselves in the relegation zone after a disappointing run of results. They have managed just one win and five draws from their opening games, leaving them 18th in the Premier League table.

Their poor start has increased the need for defensive reinforcements, with Bassey emerging as one of the players under consideration. 

United are keen to improve their backline in January, given the possibility that they could lose both Lisandro Martinez and Harry Maguire next summer.

According to reports from ESPN, the club have already drawn up a shortlist of defensive targets, which also includes Brentford centre-back Nathan Collins.

Both defenders have Premier League experience and could strengthen United’s backline. However, a move for Bassey ahead of Collins would make more sense for several reasons.

Why Manchester United should prioritise Calvin Bassey over Nathan Collins

1. Availability and transfer cost

One major reason Manchester United should favour Bassey is his contract situation, which could make him a more accessible option in January.

The Fulham defender’s current contract expires next summer, although the club have the option to extend it by another year. Nevertheless, Fulham will be aware of the risk of losing him for nothing if they do not activate that option or agree on a new deal.

With United interested, the January transfer window could represent an opportunity for Fulham to secure a transfer fee rather than risk an uncertain situation later in the year.

The situation is different for Collins, whose contract with Brentford runs until 2029. This puts the Bees in a stronger negotiating position and means they would have little reason to entertain a cheap offer.

Although both players would require a transfer fee, Bassey could represent the more financially sensible option for United.

2. Consistency and availability

Another important factor that puts Bassey ahead of Collins is his consistency and ability to remain available for selection.

The Nigerian defender has established himself as an important figure at Fulham, delivering reliable performances and showing that he can handle the demands of regular Premier League football.

His physical qualities, defensive awareness and ability to deal with different attacking threats have made him a dependable option at the back.

Bassey, who ranks as one of Fulham’s most valuable players, has also shown that he can compete at a high level against some of the Premier League’s best attackers. 

He also offers an interesting comparison with Lisandro Martinez. While the Argentine brings quality on the ball and aggression in defence, Bassey’s physical presence and ability to compete in individual battles could provide a different dimension to United’s defence.

Collins is also an established Premier League defender, but his injury record and availability concerns could make Bassey a more attractive option if United want someone they can rely on throughout a demanding season.

3. Strength in ground duels

Bassey’s physical strength and ability to compete in defensive duels are also qualities that could make him a good fit for Manchester United.

The Fulham defender is comfortable dealing with powerful forwards and can use his strength, pace and physical presence to prevent attackers from getting the better of him.

His ability to compete in one-on-one situations would be very useful for United, who need defenders capable of handling opponents without constantly relying on support from their teammates.

Bassey’s aggression and recovery pace also allow him to defend in different situations, whether against quick attackers running in behind or physically imposing forwards looking to hold up the ball.

4. Bassey’s quality on the ball and passing ability

Beyond his defensive qualities, Bassey could also improve Manchester United’s ability to build attacks from the back.

The Nigerian defender is comfortable in possession and can carry the ball forward when space opens up. Bassey’s ability to play out from the back could also make him a useful option alongside the likes of Martinez, whose passing range and composure are important to United’s style of play.

Collins is not lacking in this department either, but Bassey’s edges in terms of ball-carrying ability, and physical qualities, which makes him an interesting option for the Red Devils.

What next for Calvin Bassey?

Bassey is expected to be involved in Nigeria’s upcoming 2027 Africa Cup of Nations qualifiers against Tanzania, as the Super Eagles look to improve their position in the group.

After the international break, he will return to Fulham’s attention as they prepare for their Premier League meeting with Manchester City.