Victor Osimhen transfer: Why Al Hilal would have been a better choice than Galatasaray

Published on by

On Monday, reports of a resolution to the Victor Osimhen transfer saga surfaced online.

By most accounts, an agreement on personal terms has been reached between the 27-year-old and Galatasaray, with whom he enjoyed a fruitful 2024/25 season. Pending an acceptable bid to Napoli, the striker is set to return to Istanbul, reuniting with an adoring fanbase.

While a conclusion is welcome, this one does feel a little underwhelming, and for good reason. Because, for all that Osimhen and his associates have insisted that his transfer ambitions have nothing to do with money – a claim propped up by the refusal of numerous bids from Al Hilal – ultimately, that is precisely what it has come down to.

Victor Osimhen transfer: Why Al Hilal would have been a better choice than Galatasaray
Photo by IMAGO

Why Galatasaray choice is entirely motivated by money

First off, Galatasaray have made no secret of their desire to retain the talisman whose goals led them to great success last term. Their interest has been public and, more importantly, long-standing: as early as January, Cim Bom were talking about it.

While Victor Osimhen never dismissed it definitively, the messaging from him was, at best, non-committal at various times: his deleted farewell post, his radio silence at the start of the window, etc. If, after all that, he is turning around to agree personal terms and greenlight a move, it cannot be because he always thought of Galatasaray as the ideal destination. Instead, it is clear that, with Turkey able to meet his salary demands based on a kinder tax regime, the Nigeria international has opted to return.

In Europe’s top five leagues, tax regimes range from between 43-52%, meaning that in order to match his desired take-home salary, the likes of Manchester United, Liverpool and Arsenal would need to shell out 150% for his gross. In the Premier League, that would make him the second-highest paid player, behind only Erling Haaland.

While Osimhen’s defenders have insisted that is fair value for a striker of his calibre, consider that only three clubs are represented in the top eight of highest-paid players in the league. And one of them, Manchester City, do not need a striker. His options were never bountiful.

Galatasaray: A lukewarm choice for Victor Osimhen

So we are left with two avenues to explore. If his main goal was level of competition, then it behooved him to not be so rigid in terms of his salary demands. There simply is no way around this. If, however, he considered that enough of a deal breaker to leave the negotiating table, then the only sensible inference is that it is, in fact, money that is the primary motivation.

If it is, then one has to wonder why he did not simply go to Saudi Arabia.

Victor Osimhen transfer: Why Al Hilal would have been better choice than Galatasaray
Photo by IMAGO

In for a penny, in for a pound; if money was so important, why not take Al Hilal’s 500th offer and clean out? Turkish Super Lig clubs barely register beyond the qualifying stages of the Champions League, and another year with Galatasaray would take him even farther along his career trajectory, eating up another 12 months of his nominal prime. That shoots down any notion of a return to Turkey keeping him front of mind for the game’s giants: nothing he does this time around that will move the needle where last season did not.

Also, say what you want about the Saudi league, but Al Hilal are a top side with a world-class manager, a competitive enough squad to trouble Europe’s elite, and regular deep runs in the Asian Champions League. It would have been a wrench to see him go there in his prime, but at least it would have been a firm, bold decision one way.

Instead, in Galatasaray, especially as his actions made clear they were not his first choice, we have a lukewarm choice that tells us nothing.

<!-- Author Start -->Solace Chukwu<!-- Author End -->

Solace Chukwu

Editor Site Coordinator

Solace Chukwu is one of Africa's foremost football columnists, with over a decade of experience working with various media outlets including Goal, Guardian UK, Pulse Sports and NewFrame News. While football is his first love, he also follows and comments on boxing and tennis.